CEO & Founder of Chestnut Mortgage. NMLS #2687968. · May 12, 2026
If your FICO sits below 680, the mortgage market does not lock you out. It charges more, asks for more equity, and rewards homework. The average HELOC rate hit 7.26% in May 2026 and that is the rate for borrowers with strong files. Sub-680 borrowers pay a premium on top, but the gap to a credit card at 21.00% APR or a 24-month personal loan at 11.40% APR is still wide enough that secured borrowing usually wins.
This guide walks through what counts as “bad credit” in mortgage underwriting, which refinance programs accept sub-680 files, which HELOC structures do, and how to close the gap on your score before you apply. It covers Texas and Colorado specifically, since Chestnut lends in both. Rates and terms depend on full credit profile, not score alone.
Lenders price off FICO score, but the cliff is not at one number. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau notes credit scores run 300 to 850, and that “a higher score makes it easier to qualify for a loan and may result in a better interest rate or loan terms.” Most mortgage programs use the middle of your three bureau scores (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion).
For pricing and program access, the industry tiers look like this:
| FICO band | Mortgage label | Programs typically open |
|---|---|---|
| 760+ | Excellent | Best conventional, jumbo, all FHA and VA |
| 720 to 759 | Very good | Strong conventional pricing |
| 680 to 719 | Good | Standard conventional, all government |
| 640 to 679 | Fair | Government loans, some conventional |
| 580 to 639 | Subprime / fair | FHA at 3.5% down, FHA cash-out, VA, USDA |
| 500 to 579 | Poor | FHA at 10% down only |
| Below 500 | No agency option | Manual / non-QM with significant overlays |
For most homeowners considering a refinance or HELOC in 2026, “bad credit” practically means below 680. That is where conventional pricing starts to hurt and where some non-agency HELOC lenders draw their line. It does not mean you have no options.
Compare current Texas and Colorado rates with no credit pull before you decide whether refinancing or a HELOC fits your situation. A soft inquiry will not move your score.
The four programs below all accept sub-680 files. The right one depends on your existing loan type, how much equity you have, and whether you need cash out.
The FHA Streamline is the most forgiving refinance product in the market. If your current loan is already FHA-insured, you can refinance to a lower rate without a new appraisal, full income re-verification, or in some cases any credit pull at all.
Key rules from HUD’s single-family handbook:
Tradeoff: you keep paying FHA’s Mortgage Insurance Premium (MIP), and the upfront MIP rolls into the new loan. The CFPB notes that mortgage insurance is required for all FHA loans, so you cannot drop it the way you can drop conventional PMI at 20% equity. If your goal is to cut MIP, you need a conventional refi (and a 620+ score).
If you have an existing FHA loan or a conventional loan you want to roll into FHA pricing, the FHA cash-out can pull equity out at lower credit minimums than conventional cash-out. The 580 FICO floor for 3.5% down purchases does not apply to cash-out; FHA cash-out has tighter minimums and most lenders set their own overlay at 600 to 620 FICO.
What FHA cash-out delivers:
For a Texas borrower with 70% LTV and a 620 FICO, FHA cash-out is often the cheapest path to equity when a conventional cash-out denial sits in the file. Note the Texas 2% fee cap under Finance Code Chapter 343 applies to FHA cash-out in Texas, capping lender and broker fees at 2% of the loan amount excluding third-party costs.
The Interest Rate Reduction Refinance Loan is the most streamlined refinance in the country. The VA explicitly states “no appraisal or credit underwriting package is required when applying for an IRRRL”. There is no minimum credit score from the VA, although individual lenders will set overlays (often 580 to 620 FICO).
Requirements per the VA’s IRRRL page:
If you have a VA loan and your score has dropped since you bought, the IRRRL is almost always the answer. It does not solve cash-out needs.
Unlike IRRRL, the VA cash-out runs full underwriting and requires an appraisal. Lender overlays typically start at 580 to 620 FICO. The VA allows up to 100% LTV cash-out at the program level (the most aggressive of any major program), though most lenders cap at 90%.
Tradeoff: the VA funding fee on a cash-out runs 2.15% to 3.3% of the loan amount for non-exempt veterans. That eats into the equity you pull out. Run the breakeven before deciding.
See whether a VA cash-out beats a HELOC for your situation. Chestnut’s online comparison shows both side by side before you commit.
HELOCs are second liens, so they sit junior to your primary mortgage and price higher. The average HELOC rate is 7.26% as of May 2026, and Bankrate notes “680 has historically been the standard, but some lenders accept lower scores nowadays.”
Three structural points matter when you have sub-680 credit:
A 640 FICO file gets a “no” at one credit union and a “yes” with a rate adjustment at the next. Common minimums in 2026:
| Lender type | Typical HELOC minimum FICO | Rate adjustment for sub-680 |
|---|---|---|
| Big bank | 680 to 700 | Often declined |
| Local credit union | 660 to 680 | +0.50% to +1.00% |
| Fintech (digital) | 640 to 660 | +0.75% to +1.50% |
| Alt-doc / non-QM | 580 to 620 | +2.00% or more |
A 640 to 679 file is the borderline zone. You will get declines, but you will also get approvals. The price gap between best-in-class and “willing to lend” can be 200 to 250 basis points, so shopping matters more here than at any other credit tier.
Bad-credit HELOCs lean harder on combined loan-to-value (CLTV). The cleanest sub-680 approvals tend to have 70% CLTV or lower. At 80% CLTV with a 640 FICO, you are running against tighter overlays. At 85% CLTV with a 640 FICO, most agency-aligned lenders pass entirely.
Concrete math: a Texas home worth $400,000 with a $240,000 first mortgage (60% LTV) leaves about $80,000 of equity at 80% CLTV. Even a 640 FICO borrower can usually access most of that through a HELOC, though the rate will run 1 to 2 points above the headline 7.26% average.
Non-QM HELOC lenders (Spring EQ, Figure on certain products, some regional banks) will accept files below 620 FICO, but the rate adjustment can be steep and prepayment penalties are more common than in agency products. For Texas borrowers, remember the 2% fee cap under Finance Code Chapter 343 applies to home equity loans and cash-out refinances, but the cap excludes third-party costs like title insurance and appraisal.
For a deeper comparison of HELOC structures, see Chestnut’s guide on fast HELOC approval with bad credit strategies.
The CFPB’s official credit-improvement guidance is the right starting point. Six concrete steps:
Realistic timelines:
| Starting score | Target score | Typical timeline | Driver |
|---|---|---|---|
| 580 | 620 | 30 to 90 days | Utilization cleanup, dispute errors |
| 620 | 660 | 3 to 6 months | Payment history, balance transfers |
| 660 | 700 | 6 to 12 months | Age of credit, mix, no new inquiries |
| 700 | 740 | 12 to 24 months | Consistent low utilization + history |
Chestnut clients regularly close a refinance or HELOC at one score and refinance again 12 to 18 months later at a meaningfully higher score. The strategy is not “wait until 760” but “qualify once, optimize later.”
Texas treats home equity differently than any other state.
If you are a sub-680 Texas borrower, the FHA cash-out is often the cleanest path. Combine it with the TDI refinance title insurance discount (50% off basic premium within 4 years of purchase, 25% off between 4 and 8 years) and you can substantially cut closing costs.
Colorado is permissive by comparison.
For sub-680 Colorado borrowers, the practical advantage is broader lender selection. Where a Texas 640 FICO file might see three usable HELOC lenders, the same Colorado file might see eight. Use that to shop aggressively.
See Chestnut’s Colorado HELOC and refinance options when you are ready to compare actual quotes.
Sub-680 borrowing is more expensive borrowing. The honest version of this conversation includes:
Rates and terms depend on full credit profile, not score alone. Two borrowers with identical 640 FICO scores can see meaningfully different offers based on debt-to-income, employment history, reserves, and how the late payments on the file are distributed in time.
For an FHA Streamline Refinance on an existing FHA loan, there is no required credit score from HUD, although most lenders set an overlay at 580 to 620 FICO. For a VA IRRRL, the VA itself does not require credit underwriting, but lender overlays typically start at 580 to 620. For conventional and cash-out refinances, practical minimums start at 620 FICO with significant pricing adjustments below 680.
Yes, with a smaller pool of lenders. Big banks usually require 680 to 700 FICO for a HELOC. Credit unions and fintechs go down to 640 to 660. Alt-doc and non-QM lenders accept 580 to 620 FICO, though rate adjustments and equity requirements tighten significantly. Combined loan-to-value at or below 70% strengthens a sub-680 file substantially.
The FHA program does not require a new credit underwriting package on a Streamline Refinance, but individual lenders typically run a credit report and apply overlays. You also have to be current on payments with no 30-day lates in the past 6 months and no more than one late in 12 months. A 210-day seasoning from your original FHA closing is required.
HUD does not publish a single minimum credit score for FHA cash-out, but most lenders set overlays at 600 to 620 FICO. The maximum LTV is 80% of appraised value (reduced from 85% in 2019). FHA cash-out is one unit owner-occupied only, requires 12 months of on-time mortgage payments, and runs a full appraisal and income re-verification.
Yes. The VA IRRRL does not require credit underwriting at the VA level, though individual lenders set overlays (commonly 580 to 620 FICO). For a VA cash-out, full underwriting applies and overlays start around 580 to 620 FICO depending on lender. The VA funding fee on cash-out runs 2.15% to 3.3% of the loan amount for non-exempt veterans.
It depends on the math. A refinance from a high-rate FHA loan to a slightly lower rate via FHA Streamline often pencils even at sub-680 credit because the costs are minimal and the program is forgiving. A conventional cash-out at 640 FICO with significant pricing adjustments may not beat a HELOC at the same score. Always run the breakeven (closing costs divided by monthly savings) before committing.
Most sub-680 HELOC approvals require combined loan-to-value at or below 80%, and the cleanest approvals tend to be at 70% CLTV or lower. In Texas, the constitutional 80% CLTV cap on home equity products applies regardless of credit score. In Colorado, individual lender programs set the cap, usually 80% to 85%.
Paying down revolving balances to under 30% utilization typically delivers the fastest gains. The CFPB recommends “no more than 30 percent of available credit,” and many borrowers see 20 to 40 point increases within 30 to 60 days of cleaning up utilization. Disputing inaccurate items on your credit reports is the other fast lever. Avoid opening new accounts in the 90 days before applying.
Data and statistics referenced in this article are sourced from public mortgage industry reports and Chestnut's internal analysis.
No phone calls. No credit check. Takes 2 minutes.